AVAILABLE ALL DAY


APPETIZERS

TUNA NACHOS*

Sashimi grade ahi tuna, wonton crisps, Japanese wakame salad, sweet soy, wasabi cream & Sriracha. $14

SAUGGY DOLLAR WINGS

Fried chicken wings w/ your choice of Toon’s award winning Buffalo sauce, Island BBQ, or Sweet& Spicy Jerk. Comes w/celery sticks & Dene’s Original Blue Cheese Dressing. (VO) sub cauliflower for chicken

SMOKED WHITEFISH DIP & CRACKERS

Baked smoked whitefish dip w/capers, shallots, cream cheese, lemon, cumin, Dijon, parsley, & a dash of hot sauce. Served w/ crackers. $13

CALAMARI

Crispy flash fried calamari, “stone crab” mustard dipping sauce, lemon  $12

CONCH FRITTERS

Bahamian style conch fritters w/ peppers, garlic, onion & corn, Alabama dipping sauce & jalapeño jelly. $10


THE GYRO FIX

Local seasoned ground lamb, warm pita, tomato-cucumber relish, cucumber feta sauce, micro greens. $10

CHILI CHEESE FRIES

Basket of crispy fries topped w/ Lucy’s chili, smoked cheddar, sour cream & scallions. $10

 W/HOUSE FRIED CHIPS & SALSA

House chili spiced corn chips & home made salsa.  $6


SANDWICHES & BURGERS

HOUSE SMOKED BRISKET

15 hour smoked beef brisket, Lucy’s house BBQ sauce, fried shallots. $11 

KEY WEST GROUPER SANDWICH

Light & crispy grouper, Lucy’s Special Sauce, lettuce, tomato, pickle & a side of slaw. $13

ISLAND PULLED TURKEY

Slow smoked, pulled turkey, grilled pineapple, Island BBQ, or Sweet & Spicy Jerk sauce & slaw,

on a KIng’s Hawaiian bun. $11

BLACKENED MAHI MAHI SANDWICH*

Blackened mahi mahi, lemon-caper tartar sauce, lettuce, tomato, daikon-carrot slaw. $12 


THE FORBIDDEN BRAT

Plant based Beyond Meat bratwurst, served Chicago style, w/ an Island twist. Curried mustard sauce, sport peppers, pickled onion, tomato, sweet hottie pickles. $8


BEFORE THE BUTCHER PLANT BASED BURGER

100% vegan Beyond Meat burger on a vegan bun, dressed to your liking. $11

add vegan Daiya cheese $1


LUCY BURGER*

Half pound local ground chuck, sirloin & brisket, truffle mayo, lettuce, caramelized bacon-onion jam, & white cheddar. $12.00. w/ fries $15


BBQ BACON BURGER

Half pound local ground chuck, sirloin & brisket burger, white cheddar, house smoked bacon, buttermilk-jerk &  BBQ sauces, lettuce, tomato. $12 w/ fries $15


Regular half pound local hamburgers $10. w/ fries add $3

(American, Swiss, white cheddar. $1.00… or gorgonzola…$1.50)

SALADS

add brined chicken tenders to a salad. $5

HOUSE SALAD

Mixed greens, cucumber, onion, tomato, cashews, micro greens, Dijon vinaigrette. $7 lg $4 sm


KALE CHOPPED

House bacon, hard cooked egg, shallot, tomato, parmesan, crouton, buttermilk-cider vinaigrette. $10

(make it an entree and add flash fried calamari…$19)


BIBB LETTUCE SALAD

Bibb lettuce, goat cheese, beet-horseradish dressing, baby frisse, smoked almonds, radish, red onion, rye croutons. $10 


 

 

 

 

 

 

 

DINNER MENU

Available after 5:00 p.m.

DINNERS 

15 HOUR HOUSE SMOKED BEEF BRISKET

15 hour smoked beef brisket, Lucy’s house BBQ sauce.

Comes w/ a choice of white cheddar-horseradish-chive mashed potatoes, or French fries, & wilted greens or slaw. $19

GROUPER BASKET

Lightly battered, fried grouper, served w/ fries, lemon caper tartar sauce, & slaw. $19

Sub a house tossed salad for slaw…$21

Chicken Tiki Masala (vo)

Sautéed diced breast of chicken in a mildly spiced curry sauce w/ carrots & chickpeas, served over white rice w/ naan bread. $16.

  (vg) sub cauliflower for chicken


CALAMARI & KALE CHOPPED

Kale tossed w/ house bacon, hard cooked egg, shallot, tomato, parmesan, crouton, buttermilk-cider vinaigrette, topped w/ crispy flash fried calamari.  $19


SOUP & SIDES

Today’s Soup… Cup $3

Bowl $5

LUCY’S CHILI

(2018 CHILI COOK-OFF WINNER)

Cup $4 … Crock $6

French Fries... Basket of fries… $6  -  Single order… $3

SIDE VEG... $4 (Chef's choice of fresh vegetables)


DESSERTS

HOT APPLE FRITTERS

Warm fresh made apple cinnamon fritters, Michigan maple-rum syrup

$6

SALVADOR’S KEY LIME PIE… It’s crazy good. $8

Uncommon Coffee Roasters Coffee

$3 (free refills)

House Brewed Iced Tea

$3 (first refill free, then $1 per refill)


Soft Drinks

$2 (free refills)